The Effects of Litigation


One of my readers sent  me the following email this morning.  With his permission I’m posting it here.  Perhaps we can make a difference. Hello, I just wanted to thank you for all that you are doing to ensure that … Continue reading

Gallery | 4 Comments

Boynton Beach Police Department to Reopen for Public Records Access


The Palm Beach Post and the Sun Sentinel have reported that the City of Boynton Beach has taken steps to reopen the lobby of its Police Department.  The lobby has been closed six days per week.  Members of the public … Continue reading

Gallery | 4 Comments

A journalist is suing for access to public records from the university that published the dubious research

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Gallery | Leave a comment

The Brechner Report: Service Charges for Public Records a Bar to Access

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Gallery | 3 Comments

Mike Deeson Exposes Corruption In Hardee County

This gallery contains 3 photos.


Emmy award winning investigative journalist (and perpetual troublemaker) Mike Deeson is at it again.  This time Deeson has been poking around Hardee County. Located about an hour South of Lakeland and about an hour East of Sarasota, Hardee County is … Continue reading

Gallery | 16 Comments

This is why newspapers matter…Dozier

This gallery contains 1 photo.


From time to time I am reminded why newspapers are so important to a free and open society.  They provide the public with the ability to see what is being done in their name and at their expense. Sometimes those … Continue reading

Gallery | 3 Comments

A ‘nobody’s’ legacy: How a semi-literate ex-con changed the legal system

This gallery contains 1 photo.


I ran across an article published by NBCNews.com that I found inspirational.  It tells the story of Clarence Earl Gideon, a convicted felon who was languishing in a Florida prison in the early 1960s.  Gideon, without the assistance of counsel, filed … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

Another thoughtful editorial in the closing days of Sunshine Week

This gallery contains 1 photo.


During Sunshine Week, which ended earlier this month, numerous editorials appeared around the State of Florida.  This one was insightful and is worth consideration.  It appeared on NorthFortMyersNeighbor.com.

Gallery | Leave a comment

Brothers file new suits involving Sunshine Law in Palm Beach County

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Another article has been published by the Palm Beach Post covering a number of lawsuits filed by my brother Robert and myself.  It’s short, but worth a quick look.

Gallery | 2 Comments

Video Showing Hillsborough County School Bus Driver Kicking Disabled Child Down Step Released

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Yet another disturbing story about Hillsborough County School personnel neglecting or abusing disabled children has come to light.  While the story was originally reported months ago, only recently has the video been released. This is one more example of why … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

Carlos Miller Interviewed for Sunshine Week


My friend and colleague, Carlos Miller was interviewed by www.FloridaWatchDog.org in recognition of Sunshine Week.  On several occasions I have had the opportunity to work with Carlos documenting violations of Florida’s open government in South Florida.

Both the article and the video are worth a look.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

FOIA Shaming

This gallery contains 1 photo.


      One of my readers turned me on to a blog (see below) called FOIA Shaming.  For the uninitiated “FOIA” stands for Freedom of Information Act, which is the federal equivalent of Florida’s Public Records Act.  The acronym … Continue reading

Gallery | 1 Comment

Carlos Miller of PINAC Covers Another FOGWatch Audit


You can read more about Carlos Miller and PINAC (Photography Is Not A Crime) as well the details of our visit to the Miami Beach Police Department.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Florida First Amendment Foundation Weighs-In On Centralized Access


020

Activist Stanley Voice and FAF President Barbara Petersen discuss open government issues in a Palm Beach County

The Florida First Amendment Foundation (FAF) and FOGWatch have taken up the cause of Stanley Voice.  Stanley is an 89-year-old gentleman living in Palm Beach County, and  an advocate for the elderly and disabled.  His passion is improving public transportation for folks who otherwise would be unable to travel.

As part of his advocacy Stanley makes public records requests to demonstrate that things for these folks could and should be better.  Unfortunately, the political leadership of Palm Beach County has adopted a policy which requires citizens seeking access to public records to make their requests to a centralized location, regardless of where the public records are stored.  That policy is inconsistent with Florida’s Public Records Act.

Both the FAF and FOGWatch have appealed to Palm Beach County to reconsider their policy.  Below is a letter authored by Barbara Petersen, President of the FAF and arguably the preeminent scholar on open government law in Florida.FAF Letter to Palm Beach County on Behalf of Stanley Voice 1FAF Letter to Palm Beach County on Behalf of Stanley Voice 2

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Public records passion: Florida government watchdog sues Collier, Lee agencies


Screen Shot 2013-03-12 at 8.07.32 AM

Image | Posted on by | Leave a comment

Barriers to public records


Screen Shot 2013-03-12 at 8.05.34 AM

Image | Posted on by | Leave a comment

Sunshine Law monitors sue Boynton, others over open records


Screen Shot 2013-03-12 at 7.58.36 AM

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Without enforcement, ‘sunshine’ is dimmed


Screen Shot 2013-03-12 at 7.31.37 AM

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

First Amendment Foundation Celebrates Sunshine Week


  Two events highlight the First Amendment Foundation’s 2013 observance of Sunshine Week, the national initiative to promote a dialogue about the importance of open government and freedom of information. Sunshine Week 2013 runs from March 10-16. Sunshine Recognition Luncheon: … Continue reading

Gallery | 1 Comment

Finally


Over the years I’ve made thousands of public records requests and conducted hundreds of audits. Unfortunately, the performance of most public agencies and state contractors that are subject to Florida’s exceptionally broad open government laws has been poor. Some of … Continue reading

Gallery | 11 Comments

Dear Defendant


In Florida access to public records and public meetings is a constitutionally protected civil right.  See Article 1, Section 24 of the Florida Constitution. I’m a civil rights advocate; so much of my time is spent auditing public agencies for … Continue reading

Gallery | 4 Comments

The Best Part of My Job


With photojournalist Carlos Miller outside of the Miami Beach Police Department after an audit.  They failed.

With Carlos Miller outside of the Miami Beach Police Department after an audit. They failed.

Last week FOGWatch took its show on the road to South Florida.  We visited some old friends and made new ones.  This is the best part of my job.

Every day I am contacted by folks around the Sunshine state asking for help with access to public records and pubic meetings.  I am not an attorney, so I can’t give legal advice, however, having made thousands of public records requests and filed (and won) more than 100 open government lawsuits I do have some insight about how the system works.

Due to that experience folks ask for my input on their situations.  Since I don’t give legal advice I try to be a sounding board.  In addition to providing a sympathetic ear, I share with these folks what I might do were I similarly situated.

The FOGWatch entourage brainstorming about open government issues in South Florida.

The FOGWatch entourage brainstorming about open government issues in South Florida.

Stanley Voice (left) and Joel Chandler (right). Stanley is one of the most delightful people I've met in a long time. He is committed to the rights of the elderly and disabled, and a credit to Palm Beach County.

Stanley Voice (left) and Joel Chandler (right). Stanley is one of the most delightful people I’ve met in a long time. He is committed to the rights of the elderly and disabled, and a credit to Palm Beach County.

These folks have their own unique windmills with which to tilt, but the basic facts are almost always the same.  Some  public official is trying to frustrate their civil rights.

Their stories are often interesting and infuriating.  They have uncovered corruption, abuse and outright theft.  Sometimes they are themselves trying to advocate for some decent cause but their efforts are stymied by the ignorance, indifference and lawlessness of the very people who are being paid to help them.

Because I am passionate about open government and civil rights these meetings don’t really feel like work. I love my work and I hope that it shows.

I have no doubt that some of the stories we’ve heard will end up in the press.  Hopefully, these stories will bring about real change and result in the strengthening of all of our civil rights.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Revealing “the hidden tension.”


In a recent television interview former School Board of Polk County member and former Mayor of Lakeland, Frank O’Reilly objected to my advocacy for open government when he described my methods as “gotcha” activism.  That’s an objection that I’ve heard … Continue reading

Gallery | 4 Comments

BayNews 9 Covers FOGWatch In-Person Audits

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Yesterday a television news crew tagged along with me while I did a short in-person audit of several public agencies in Lakeland. Rick Elmhorst of BayNews 9 asked if he and his cameraman, Calvin, could shadow me as I did … Continue reading

Gallery | 16 Comments

Florida Senate President Says FOGWatch “performs a public service.”

This gallery contains 1 photo.


This morning the Tampa Bay Times (formerly the Saint Petersburg Times) published an article about FOGWatch.  The article went into some detail about our in-person public records audits and some of the subsequent litigation. In the article Florida Senate President … Continue reading

Gallery | 4 Comments

Joel Chandler, Open Government Guru, Slaps South Florida Cities With Lawsuits


The following article was published this morning by the Broward-Palm Beach New Times: Joel Chandler, Open Government Guru, Slaps South Florida Cities With Lawsuits By Kyle Swenson Published Mon., Jan. 21 2013 at 9:00 AM On the national stage, Florida … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

Back-and-forth over Transparency 2.0 includes eye-opening Alan Hays comment

This gallery contains 1 photo.


The Orlando Sentinel published an article on January 17, 2013 titled “Back-and-forth over Transparency 2.0 includes eye-opening Alan Hayes comment.”  That’s the same day that FOGWatch addressed the Florida Senate Committee On Government Oversight and Accountability regarding the efficacy of Transparency … Continue reading

Gallery | 7 Comments

FOGWatch: Florida Senate Committee on Government Oversight and Accountability

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Yesterday, I had the opportunity to speak before the Florida Senate Committee on Government Oversight and Accountability regarding Transparency 2.0.  (The full video may be seen by clicking the photo above or clicking here). Transparency 2.0 is a web site … Continue reading

Gallery | 3 Comments

FOGWatch Goes to Tallahassee

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Today I had the opportunity to meet with Florida Senate President Don Gaetz (R-District 1) about various open government issues.  Senator Gaetz was joined by his Chief of Staff Chris Clark. The nearly one hour meeting covered a variety of … Continue reading

Gallery | 3 Comments

Editorial Admonished Lakeland Police Chief Over Public Records Violations


In a tersely worded editorial, the Lakeland Ledger has called out Lisa Womack, the Chief of the Lakeland Police Department.  Last week the Ledger reported that Womack admitted that under her direction the Lakeland PD plays “cat and mouse” games … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

FOGWatch On Live Radio


On Monday, January 14, 2013 I will be appearing on a live call-in radio show called “Law Talk.”  The show is broadcast by WLKF in Lakeland on 1430 AM at 5:00 PM.

The show will be a discussion of open government issues including the activism of FOGWatch.org and various open government lawsuits.  Best of all, members of the public  can call in to ask questions, make comments or discuss open government issues.

Please join me live on the air for what will hopefully be a lively conversation.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Carlos Miller of PINAC (Photography Is Not A Crime) Covers FOGWatch



Coral Gables Police Department

Our good friend and fellow-travler Carlos Miller has posted several videos of one of our recent roadshows. Miller operates the wildly popular blog, Photography Is Not A Crime (PINAC).

Miller, a credentialed photojournalist, has been repeatedly arrested and prosecuted for photographing LEOs. So far he’s been acquitted each time, including winning his appeal as a Pro Se defendant. As you’ll see from the video, Carlos has not been intimidated by his previous encounters with LE.


Miami Police Department

For the sake of full-disclosure, Carlos is my friend and we (Robert and I) stayed at his condo during our visit to the Magic City.  But as anyone who knows Carlos can attest, I had no control over what Carlos decides to do with a camera. We did not put him up to video tapping our field trip. He decided to do that all on his own.


Department of Management Services

Minus the hysteria caused by the presence of a video camera, these encounters are actually remarkably typical of our in-person audits.

Video | Posted on by | 6 Comments

She Talked Me Into It


Transparency is important. I make a big deal about state and local agencies (and those acting on their behalf) being open about what they are doing in the public’s name and at the public’s expense. Although, http://www.FOGWatch.org is not in … Continue reading

Gallery | 1 Comment

www.FOGWatch.org Welcomes Its First Staff Members

This gallery contains 1 photo.


The readers of http://www.FOGWatch.org may have noticed some changes to the site lately.  There are several reasons for that and their names are Anna, Hope and Grace Grover.  These three wonderful ladies have volunteered to become the first staff members … Continue reading

Gallery | Leave a comment

www.FOGWatch.org Plans to Seek Non-Profit Status

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Since my first foray into open government issues back in 2007, for the most part, I’ve been laboring alone.  Certainly, I’ve had the benefit of excellent legal representation, principally from the wonderful minds at Thomas & LoCicero.  I’ve also had, … Continue reading

Gallery | Leave a comment

Answers to More Questions


One of my readers, “James”, posted a series of questions under the blog post “More News Reports About Boynton Beach Lawsuits.”  Instead of answering James’ questions within the comments section I’ve decided to address them in a new blog post.  James … Continue reading

Gallery | 10 Comments

Lakeland Police Department Chief Admits to “Cat and Mouse” Games With Public Records

This gallery contains 1 photo.


    In a stunning revelation to The Lakeland Ledger, Lakeland Chief of Police Lisa Womack has admitted that it is the policy of the LPD to play games with public records requests.  To the uninitiated that may be a … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments

Some Defendants Claim FOGWatch Engages In “Gotcha” Litigation


Over the past several weeks, Robert and I have filed dozens of new public records lawsuits. All of these lawsuits stem from our in-person audits of public agencies and state contractors who are expressly subject to Florida’s Public Records Act. … Continue reading

Gallery | 10 Comments

More News Reports About Boynton Beach Lawsuits

This gallery contains 1 photo.


The Sun Sentinel has published an article about my lawsuit against the Boynton Beach Police Department and my brother Robert’s lawsuit against the City of Boynton Beach.  In both instances, the lawsuits deal with institutionalized policies that violate Florida’s Public … Continue reading

Gallery | 7 Comments

President of “Non-Profit” State Contract Paid $1.2 Million Compensation

This gallery contains 1 photo.


In an article written by Steve Bousquet and published by various newspaper, including the Lakeland Ledger, it has been reported that William Schossler, President of the nonprofit Henry & Rilla White Foundation was paid $1.2 million in 2010. The Henry … Continue reading

Gallery | 4 Comments

Palm Beach Post Reports On FOGWatch Lawsuit Against Boynton Beach Police Department

This gallery contains 1 photo.


The Palm Beach Post has reported that the Boynton Beach Police Department is being sued for violations of Florida’s Public Records Act.  The article states that “Joel Edward Chandler” filed the lawsuit.  That is correct. The lawsuit is one of … Continue reading

Gallery | 5 Comments

Lawsuit Against the School Board of Polk County Settles

This gallery contains 1 photo.


The Lakeland Ledger has reported that School Board of Polk County voted yesterday to accept the terms of a proposed settlement agreement, which will bring to a close, my third lawsuit against the School Board. Later today, I will also … Continue reading

Gallery | 4 Comments

In the Hands of the State – Youth and Death In Florida

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Generally, I limit my blog posts to brief commentaries about public records and open meetings issues or simple links to news stories and editorials on the subject. Over the past few of weeks, however, a series of stories have come … Continue reading

Gallery | 4 Comments

Public Records: School Board Emails

This gallery contains 1 photo.


Although, I am posting this somewhat tardily, it’s worth noting (and reading) that The Lakeland Ledger published an thoughtful editorial regarding the apparent failure of the School Board of Polk County to comply with Florida’s Public Records Act.  Hopefully, the … Continue reading

Gallery | 1 Comment

Transparency 2.0


News reports and editorials (see the Orlando Sentinel and the Tampa Bay Times) have revealed that the Florida Senate paid more than $5 million to develop a web site that would have allowed the public to see amazing amounts of … Continue reading

Gallery | Leave a comment

Mike Deeson Wins Emmy for “In God We Trust” Report


Screen Shot 2012-12-18 at 4.29.15 PMTelevision reporter Mike Deeson of WTSP has won another Emmy.  This time Deeson won an Emmy for his report on the “In God We Trust” tag scandal.

The basis for Deeson’s story was a series of public records that revealed that hundreds of thousands of dollars paid to the “In God We Trust Foundation” went missing as the result of malfeasance.  Thousands of “In God We Trust” specialty tags were sold to unsuspecting motorists who believed their money was being used to support grants for the widows and orphans of fallen first repsonders.

In fact, all but about $10,000 of the more than $400,000 raised to support needy folks was squandered by the Foundation’s president.  As a result of Deeson’s report the Florida Highway Patrol launched a criminal investigation of the Foundation.

Congratulations to Mike Deeson for his award and his fine reporting of this important story.

Aside | Posted on by | Leave a comment

More FCIC Abuse

This gallery contains 1 photo.


One of the most well established principles of open government law in Florida, is that, with very few exceptions, we have the right to inspect, photograph and copy public records and to attend open meetings without having to explain why … Continue reading

Gallery | 4 Comments

The Public Table

This gallery contains 1 photo.


As I’ve mentioned in previous posts, Robert and I have been crisscrossing the state conducting in-person-audits of public agencies to check for compliance with Florida’s Public Records Act. We have done audits in Manatee, Pinellas, Hillsborough, Pasco, Polk, Lake, Putnam, … Continue reading

Gallery | 3 Comments

Arthur G. Dozier School for Boys: Why Open Government Matters


The Arthur G. Dozier School for Boys is, perhaps, the best example of why open government matters in Florida.  If you believe this sort of thing could never happen again, I invite you to visit any juvenile detention facility in the State of Florida and make a public records request.  I have, and not one has ever complied with Florida’s Public Records Act.  You have to wonder what they are hiding.

Posted in Uncategorized | 7 Comments

Papers Please!

This gallery contains 1 photo.


The photograph above was taken on December 4, 2012 outside of a building owned and operated by the Florida Department of Management Services, (“DMS”), on behalf of the citizens of Florida. This particular facility houses numerous other Florida State agencies, … Continue reading

Gallery | 2 Comments